Humint Events Online: 33 of the Day: the Never-Ending Civil War in America

Sunday, April 12, 2015

33 of the Day: the Never-Ending Civil War in America

Appomattox, like the Civil War more broadly, retains its hold on the American imagination. More than 330,000 people visited the site in 2013.
Not the obvious use of 33 here. This piece is from today's NYtimes, yet they use a figure from 2013, not 2015. Also note the "more than" trick, that allows the nice clear 330,000 number, rather than the specific number.

The piece itself has some good history:
To enforce its might over a largely rural population, the Army marched across the South after Appomattox, occupying more than 750 towns and proclaiming emancipation by military order. This little-known occupation by tens of thousands of federal troops remade the South in ways that Washington proclamations alone could not. And yet as late as 1869, President Grant’s attorney general argued that some rebel states remained in the “grasp of war.” 
When white Georgia politicians expelled every black member of the State Legislature and began a murderous campaign of intimidation, Congress and Grant extended military rule there until 1871. Meanwhile, Southern soldiers continued to fight as insurgents, terrorizing blacks across the region. One congressman estimated that 50,000 African-Americans were murdered by white Southerners in the first quarter-century after emancipation. “It is a fatal mistake, nay a wicked misery to talk of peace or the institutions of peace,” a federal attorney wrote almost two years after Appomattox. “We are in the very vortex of war.” 
Against this insurgency, even President Andrew Johnson, an opponent of Reconstruction, continued the state of war for a year after Appomattox. When Johnson tried to end the war in the summer of 1866, Congress seized control of his war powers; from 1867 to 1870, generals in the South regulated state officials and oversaw voter registration, ensuring that freedmen could claim the franchise they had lobbied for. With the guidance of military overseers, new biracial governments transformed the Constitution itself, passing the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments. 
The military occupation created pockets of stability and moments of order. Excluded from politics before the war, black men won more than 1,500 offices during Reconstruction. By 1880, 20 percent of black families owned farms. But the occupation that helped support these gains could not be sustained. Anxious politicians reduced the Army’s size even as they assigned it more tasks. After Grant used the military to put down the Ku Klux Klan in the Carolinas in 1871, Congress and the public lost the will to pay the human and financial costs of Reconstruction.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Might be interesting if there was
any evidence for this 33 stuff -- rather than mere speculation.

Correlation does not mean causation.

10:10 PM  
Blogger spooked said...

the last few 33's I've posted on have clearly showed the 33 was no accident.

Why people use 33 is another issue, but it's clearly on purpose.

11:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

No evidence for your 33 obsession has ever been presented.

It's time for you to end this. Or, is it a sign that you are being controlled? Willing agent?

2:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Powered by Blogger